Saturday, January 22, 2011

Bengali Rock Album Review 6 - Chapter 2 (Prithibi) - Teaser

 I just found out that Prithibi has released their second album in 2010 called Chapter 2. Their first and self titled album that I reviewed  earlier was released in 2007. I am not reviewing it right away. But my first hearing of the album has the following comments -

Better recording. Better composition. Completely different musical allegiance.

I also learned that the one song that i did not like the most in their first album, was their single most greatest hit - O AMAR!!!!! So there you are. I wish my blog was read by more people who echoed my sentiments. At this point I feel completely depressed about the fact that O Amar is their single most hit song..!!! Comments guys ??

Quite expectedly therefore Prithibi's lyrics is more romance oriented. Quite "emo" actually.
And in a way reminds me of Fossils or Rupam.

More later....... see you all.

19th January, 2011


Go to the Bengali Rock Search Index

Bengali Rock Album Review 5 - Prithibi (Prithibi) Part 2

This is the actual review of the band. I wrote it shortly after my last post but I wanted to write an intro to it because I know the review is far less detailed and quite harsh. Prithibi -  if fortunately or unfortunately, any of you are reading this blog and do not agree with me or my views .... curse my blog, curse me and move on. If you do think there is some sort of creative criticism that you can use from this, please do so.

Truly speaking, while I would only give them 3 stars out of 10 ( a new method to have  a comparative feel to these reviews) , both their guitarists are exceptional. Their background vocals are brilliant and their vocalist does often reach the right keys and tones to remind you of shades of Axel Rose or Dickinson. Their keyboards need to tighten up, their bassist needs more confidence, their lyricist needs more books to read and their drummer has a long way to go. LONG LONG WAY.  Here is the complete review. If you can read Bengali , this is the link for their lyrics (http://www.prithibimusic.com/lyrics.htm) and you can find the songs in youtube if you type the names along with Prithibi.


First Song - Asukh (Disease) - The song starts with  a good piano intro leading to the guitar arpeggio . The vocals are actually good when it starts and the background harmony is also pretty good. The song has a good atmospheric feeling but somehow the scale change in the vocals midway of the stranza sounds a little dischordant. And just when i was thinking it would be okay to call it to be well inspired by 80's rock they introduce sonic boom probably by means of a synth and that really does not fit in. The song ends low key and I dont think I will remember the song.

Barudh (Gun powder) - Good intro. Has a tinge of Iron Maiden in the beginning, but the slow piano interlude removes that. The lyrics are okay but not the best. A minute into the song, I am disappointed that a song aptly named barudh can have such meek vocals. The background vocals once again are really good. The chorus of the song reminds me of both Guns and Roses and White Lion, so full marks to Prithibi for getting the 80s hard rock influence. If only they could get it consistently right, for once again they use a wierd synthesiser sound which kind of makes the song less serious. This maynot be a creative limitation but also lack of good sound effects. Lets hope it is that. The song has another stranza which is only different from the first in its ending guitar lead which I have to agree is very good. But nonetheless, this 7 minute song could easily, EASILY have been a 3.5 minute song.

Biplob Dirghajibi Hok (Long Live Revolution) - Finally some solid beats starting the song. Sounds straight out of an GnR album. The song has good lyrics. Probably one of the best in the album. The lyrics are simple but not crass. By now the lead guitarist has impressed me a lot and if this band has gained any popularity it is for the guitarist(s). The bassist is yet to make a mark. This one song has a good piano interlude but till now the keyboardist has rather disappointed me and well the vocalist really needs to hear more of hard rock to really know what throwing your voice really is.

Brishti (Rain) - Bad intro. But the song picks up with the guitar groove - standard NWOBHM groove and they ruin it with an abrupt ending, but I guess thats their creativity. The overall feel of the song once again is pretty much the same. I am sorry if this sounds repetitive, but thats what this album feels like . A repeated attempt to introduce bengali band music lovers to NWOBHM music with soft vocals, some excellent lyrics, some half hearted serious writing and an over all khichudi of attempts. Brishti as a song does not remind me of rainfall in any way as does Riders in the Storm (Doors) or for that matter even Rainmaker (Iron Maiden). The song starts of powerful but falls flat on its face by the end. I am not surprised.

Kritodas (Slave) -lyrically referring only to the concept of slavery in medieval ages, this song fails to connect with me in the slightest manner. The music especially the guitaring is spot on. Who is this guy ? i am not sure which one of the two, Bubun or Samarpan plays the leads in these songs, but great work guys. But the song, if I may is rather insensitive. It tells a slave about the problems of his life. That too in a rather insensitive manner. The song boasts of in your face lyrics probably surprising some few Bengali Middle class youths who havent read enough fiction, literature or even sci-fi or comics all of which handle the issue of slavery in a rather delicate manner.

Manabi (Daughter of a Man) - Prithibi band members - whoever your lyricist is , he is definitely trying to hard to make a difference to the society and its a good concept but it wont help unless your lyrics makes some sort of coherent meaning. Of all the songs this song does have some sort of direction in terms of lyrics and yet it falls short. It refers to the city, probably Kolkata, as a girl and pleads it to revive itself. No extra comments about the rest of the song.

Nisshidho Parowana (Forbidden Notice) - My favorite song of the album if I HAVE to choose one. Good music. Decent lyrics. Good overall feel. Hear it guys.


O amar - (Oh Mine or She is Mine) (!!!!!!!) - this one is straight out of a MILES album. i can pause the song right now, and without remember the few times I have heard this song before I can say, the song has weak vocals, repetitive lines, background distorted guitar chords, one solid good guitar lead, a hap hazard keyboard interlude, rather simple drumming and together a boring song. This is bengali rock at its romantic worst. Why do these guys write these songs? and sing them and then make us listen to them. Listen to this song to know what NOT to do if you have a good guitarist in your band and you claim to be inspired by Ugly Kid Joe. This song should really be named Oh My God. Its a 8 minute long torture and could have saved these guys a lot of money for not recording this one. Only one thing comes to my mind in their defense. Maybe their record label asked them to put in one romantic , soft song and they had to make this one in a hurry. Other than that, I accuse Prithibi of completely annihilating 8 minutes of my life into a nothingness that I cant ever get back. Multiply that to the few times I have heard this album only to write this review and it might even be a sizeable amount of time to asphyxiate me to death. Any lawyer friends interested to fight a case ??

Pagol (Madman) -  Intro that a guitarist would not be proud of. These guys have expressed their love for Cactus and Fossils. But come on guys. You cant just mix them up together and make a song out of it. I realise that I have one more song left after this and it gives me a feeling of relief. While I realise that this is the best time to write a few lines about the drummer, the song has reached midway. The lyrics even though walking almost in the borderline of being crass actually makes sense. Although the writing invariably stinks of trying to hard to be cool and abstract it does reach that level where it could be considered as avant-garde and different. A niche this band tried to hard to reach but according to me never really succeeded. The song outro disappoints me but I guess once again I am not surprised.

Satidaha ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sati_(practice) ) - I really feel bad for the guitarists. The vocalist has constantly let him down with his pitch never reaching the pitch that would do these lyrics or at least the song names justice. The bassist either by choice or by accident has volume turned low in most of the songs. I can hear him but I am not sure if these songs would be very different without a bass guitar. The lyricist (whoever it is) has good intentions of making a social statement. But treating issues such as these which are not relevant anymore only appeals to pseudointels of a certain genre -  ineducated antels. And finally the drummer. I am not sure if he understands what sort of a group he is part of, but some one needs to tell him how big a role he plays in the composition of a song and not just playing behind the guitar leads and vocal solos. I dont remember a single double bass roll. I dont think he can give a continuous 2 bar drum roll. Almost all the songs are simple 8/8 with an ocassional crash. Hell, I dont even think he uses a drum kit too often because his gear includes a Roland SPD-11 and a "personalized drum kit". No mention of specific toms, snares or cymbals. I am not sure if he really owns one, because he certainly doesnt play one as one would. Satidaha as a song probably can only be compared to the fire that burns under the already burnt wood with flames that you cannot see. You need a whiff of fresh air to rekindle the flame quite similar to the band and its musical sound in general.

Thats all for now. I really dont have the energy to write another one because this was tiring. I will now listen to some real 80s Rock to convince myself that I dont hate the decade.

19th January, 2011


Go to the Bengali Rock Search Index

Bengali Rock Album Review 5 - Prithibi (Prithibi) Part 1

It seems to me that this band has been in the Kolkata Band circuit for quite some time, by which I mean about 5-6 years. Somehow I had not got hold of their album till about 2 yrs back and that too because I heard they were ranked second in a widely acclaimed Rock Band Competition aired on regional television. So, automatically, I was curious and downloaded their albums from esnips along with Eshaan, the band that came first. I will follow up with a review on Eshaan/Ishaan after this but right now its Prithibi! :)

The question however is why I did not review them all this while...

A very simple answer is because in order to review them I had to hear their songs over and over again to be fair and unbiased and provide a good thorough judgement. Actually I take my word back. I am, in no way, judging them. Who the @#%@ am I to judge a professional band that is and will make a lot of money singing their kind of music etc etc. So I would say , all I am doing is trying to create a regular blog on the internet to provide a complete picture of what Bengali Band music is all about and if there would be even 3 people who after reading this blog would go hear a Bengali Band even if they dont understand the lyrics and.... like them, I would consider it a huge success. I would not deny I picture this blog to be something like Chuddy Buddy Ashish's Indian Undergound Podcast. I believe in the revolution that is currently taking place in the Bengali Band scenario in West Bengal and I believe in the success of these and others from Bangladesh. But coming back to the answer, while a review necessarily requires me to go hear the songs at least 5 times, I am really really sad to say Prithibi's first album is NOT one that I would listen to 5 times willingly.

I will explain why. But let it be known I do not have anything against anyone of the band. I dont even know them. Neither do I allow my own musical preferences to cloud my opinions when it comes to these band reviews. Yes of course, till the point of time I get requests from my readers about a certain band to be reviewed by me, I will review these bands in order of complete randomness ocassionally sprinkled with my unbound enthusiasm about a specific album and I would have certain favorite songs in an album, but thats natural isnt it ?

So, I decided, actually yesterday that I will give it a shot and if I cannot really continue writing the review with Prithibi playing on my ears for the entire time I will try at a different time. It didnt happen yesterday, because I thought I could see their influence from their music and so I went and read about them, their website, articles about them and realised I was not too far off. Believe you me, the two words that came to me when I heard 3 of their songs back to back for the first time was White Lion and Glam Rock and lo and behold... they are really honest about their love for the band and the genre. Thats one thing I like about these guys. Their honesty. Or at least their apparent honesty 3 yrs ago when they were just coming in to the scene. So I then went and heard a handful of songs of their other two influences, Lifehouse and Ugly Kid Joe. Yes. I had not heard more than one song each of both of these two bands and so that was a good experience. And now I am back with a much better opinion about Prithibi as a band and their debut self-titled album.

Normally I try to do these reviews in one sitting but I think I have achieved that in only two cases. Once for Prachir and recently for Arbovirus. I guess Prachir happened in one go because I was and am still quite enthusiastic about their first album. Arbovirus was written in the Dubai airport and I had enough time to spend. Today its not going to happen for a completely different reason. I am in Lab right now, its 2 AM. and I am looking at another night out after last night to complete my set of reactions to achieve the natural product that needs to ship out on Monday. And there will be breaks to set up the reaction, take an NMR, column chromatography and other mundane things. So here is my break number 1. For the NMR. Will come back in a while. In the meantime maybe you can check out my other reviews if you are a new reader. If you arent, I trust you to spend your time more wisely! :) One last thing before I leave the keyboard. I am sorry I did promise the next band to be reviewed would be Nemesis but I really want to get these four bands out of the way before I review Nemesis. So the bands I would like to review after Prithibi would be Eshaan/Ishaan ( I really dont know how to spell them in English cause different websites spell it differently), Adhar, Arfigence and Missing Link.

I will be back.

16th January, 2011


Go to the Bengali Rock Search Index

Bengali Rock Album Review 4 - 64m 53s (Arbovirus)

I pick up the headphones , plug them into my laptop, start itunes and the moment the intro of the first song reaches my ears only one thought comes to my mind. Surprisingly the same one that has come back to me over and over again everytime I have started listening to this album. The fact that I havent heard all of Creed or Alterbridge enough number of times to do justice to them or Arbovirus' originality. I have acquired all of Creed's music very recently and will do that comparative analysis at some later point of time but right now lets focus on the job at hand.

How is Arbovirus' album 64m 53s ?

Arbovirus is a Bengali Rock Band from Bangladesh and has been in the circuit for quite some time I believe. Not only have I heard a full album from them before this I have also been ignorant enough to really not hear any of their music before. So I apologise to the hardcore Arbovirus infected out there for daring to write a review about a band whose evolution I have not monitored. But trust me I have only good things to say about them. So maybe you can be patient for a little longer. Also if anyone here reading this post is closer to any of the bengali bands please let them know that I am trying to make this a more regular affair and if the band members think I do a good job in understanding their music and the message they are trying to send I would be glad to review a new album if they sent it to me or even their myspace links.
Bengali Rock Music has reached its tipping point and the revolution has begun. The faster we come out of our Classic Rock and Folk Rock phase and evolve into a more compact, professional music base (fans included) the better it would be for the industry as well as the future bands.

64m 53s is an unique album. Many times in this post I will come back to this same thing about the professionalism of Bangladeshi bands and since this is my first post about any Bangladeshi Rock Band I guess its the best time to give them the rounds of applause that they deserve for being a far more - tighter , creative, at times 100times harder and much much more open to experiments - musical force and this album just by its sheer name underlines the same.

The first song Shikarokti (Confession) starts of with a guitar solo that reminds you of Mark Tremonti and no one else. Slide guitar style, overdrive guitars with a subdued gain, off key chord progressions and almost when you are going to write them off as another core alternative band having the same gods as most other alternative bangladeshi band, starts the vocals. Honestly I have heard better Bengali Rock vocals than Sufi but together with the rest of the band the way his voice kept the first song as tight as a dead man's fist was really the only thing that kept me listening.

No doubt the musical prowess of the band was unquestionable. What I wanted to hear was some good music. I have told my readers earlier and even now that although the bands or albums I have till date reviewed are all the ones that I really like there have been quite a few that just glue my finger to the next button solely because they just dont have the zing and are either simply cheap and lazy rip offs of Fossils or Warfaze or are wannabees with a lot of spare time and money. Arbovirus are neither.

This is driven more forcefully by their next song Uttaradhikar (Right to Succession). 30 seconds into the song and after a very innocent guitar loop, you hear a faint remembrance of an old Nirvana chord groove ending very abruptly to the original loop and the vocalist taking it from there. Sufi's voice has both maturity and boyish ness. At times in the album it tries more than it can achieve but in this song it once again blends beautifully to the really significant bass line and the constant overdriven rythm guitars and some very powerful drumming till the guitar lead takes over and you really dont realize that its 4 minutes up and they have indeed produced a fine alternative track and left you with wanting more.

Ja Icche Tai (Whatever the mind wants) starts with a very soft acoustic guitar background and only the high hat groove leading to once again a very significant bassline. By now I realise that one of the greatest successes of this band is to not ignore what Bangladeshi Rock Music is really all about - a bunch of really really great bassists. The song boasts of very very touching lyrics. A short song it really makes you happy and sad at the same time. No sharp tones. No head banging and yet its a good really good rock song.

Mukut Chhara Raja ( King without his crown) once again has the bass channel turned up to a notch that says "Dont Ignore Me". Progressive from the start the vocals start off well but some how dont end up well at the first break of the song. Starting again from the second stranza, the voice somehow tries to regain its conviction and does a good job till the really high point of the song comes for the last one minute when the guitar really comes in the fore front. It was probably a deliberate to not give it the lead channel till the last lead even though you could hear the lead through out .To me the song is good to hear but fails to leave a big impression. I blame it on a somewhat half hearted effort to make the song sound really good as a unit and thereby failing to underline at least one individual brilliant peace of musical artistry.

Adhar O Isshor (Darkness and God) the fifth song of the album starts with a reverse loop intro (music recorded earlier and then played reverse and recorded as the intro of the song) leading to a very simple guitar pluck lead with a very short delay along with a really good peace of drumming ultimately leading to a very very fresh and deep set of lyrics done perfect justice by the vocals, with the reverse loop continuing througout the song. The song excels in successive layering. The guitar intro lead goes above the reverse loop. the drum and the delay goes on the lead. the vocals come on top of all that. The bass fits itself somewhere in between (surprisingly not a very significant part of the song ) and all the layers come out at certain points of the song. till at about the 4th minute the guitar intro steals my heart completely along with a really really fine peace of drumming. The song talks about a guy trying all sorts of different things including isolation wanting to see darkness and it is right at this point after the guitar lead that they throw the punchline

" shudhai takey jomat badha andhar dekhtey dao amaye,
ishot heshe, jowab ashey, tobey tomaye isshor hote hobey,
hotey hobey .... isshor"


loosely translated it means "I asked him how can I see concentrated Darkness, with a faint smile he replied, for that you have to be God, you have to be the Lord." It is on the word lord that the background guitar lead comes and joins and finally fades away with the last 10 seconds being just feedback and to me that counts for that shows the attitude of the band and its perfect. This song on my list is far ahead than most of the others and is definitely my best song of the album.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGEXnOf0sdw

Prithibir Sesh Prantey - Somebody please translate this for me. I cant find a poetic enough translation for this song.
A slow three note guitar intro , reasonably side stick drum layer, Sufi's voice echoing out into a falsetto and before you know it its 2 minutes into the song and my feet is tapping to the rather complex yet not too distant 3/3/2 drumming. I dont know what to call this song because I only pretend to be a music know-all but am not one and therefore do not know the exact classifications of different genres of rock. To me this would fall in the category of just rock. You will hear something similar in Travis or Coldplay or maybe even the modern Oasis albums. Everybody does justice to their parts in the song -the guitar lead, the rather atmospheric background vocals , the nicely intertwined bass line and the song finally ends with an outro of the song being very same as the intro .

Amader Gaan ( Our Song ) - This beautiful song begins with a very very nicely done piano intro. I am convinced that the piano intro and the tune is influenced by a very well known pop song but I cannot remember it. Help me out here guys. The vocals and the lyrics of the song once again are soft as the song requires lamenting about the uncertain future of the band and their music and this song is therefore a request , rather a prayer in waiting. 80s rock personified the song however is the first of the next few rather short (4 minute songs). There is a hint of psychedelia but so little that I really didnt sense it :)

I personally like the short songs in this album and I believe that the band is brilliant in creating an atmosphere that lasts for four minutes and then leads to the next one. I guess that also makes financial sense. In a 60 minute tape you get more songs in and the chances of one of them becoming really popular increases . Rather naive you may say.. but right now we are not talking about the strategies but rather the music.

Omanush ( Inhuman noun) the next song experiments with definitive American Heavy Metal Music and trust me if I say heavy. Maybe not sepultura heavy but definitely Megadeth and Pantera heavy. Their Wikipedia page suggests that they are heavily influenced by pantera and nirvana and this song definitely proves that song. Starting from the opening chant to the really familiar chord pattern to the guitar lead , the song reeks and speaks of every metal song Indian and Bangladeshi metal heads are fond of. This song apparently was the most popular from this album and knowing the history of bangladeshi rock music I am not surprised.

A note once again to my Calcutta Rock music fans. While we were happy with Parashpathor and Cactus and sometime Chandrabindu belting out one track after another about unreciprocated love, lost love, defeated love, folk love and other forms of sad romantic love songs based highly on synthesisers and octopads and rather primitive in their structure, Bangladeshi Rock Music by the same time had not only experimented with the same love blind pop-rock, evolved into British and American Heavy Metal and had even started flirting with Thrash, Death metal and Hardcore. This is one of the reasons why I loved Fossils and still do. They started it all man in Calcutta.

Anyways I will always come back to this over and over again so lets not dilly dally and get to the next song -Chhaya Manush (Man in the Shadow). A song that starts with lyrics like the following will obviously catch my attention just because they are deep or at least pretend to be so.

" Amake Chenar Chesta Koro Na, Amake Chintey Tumi Parbey Na.
Majhe Majhe Ayenar Shamney Dariye, Proshno kori nijekey, tumi key, tumi key "

translation - " Dont try to understand me, You will not be able to,
At times I stand in front of the mirror and ask who are you, who are you "

Before I go into an hour long praise of this song I would just like to say this song is my next favorite song to Adhar O Ishhor. I love the guitar effects of this song, the slow distortion, classic rock sound, rather simple chord structure and drum beat (3/4??), the long guitar solo, the really really brilliant lyrics and i can go on of how much I am obsessed and proud to hear a really good classic rock song coming out of a bengali band's album. This is the kind of song that arbovirus plays really best. The song ends once again with a faded feedback and by know it seems to be a pattern one of them or all of them likes. Or its probably the guitarist who really wants the sound to linger. Thumbs up because it works.

Corporate Anthem - When I first heard this song I was actually did not like it. I still dont like it so much as far as the lyrics are concerned, which obviously, as the name suggests talk about the nuances of the boring yet stressful corporate life. I should admit here that while I love psychedelia and Floyd and Yes and other pseudo intel bands I also love Iron Maiden and Judas Priest and thats whats this song sounds like. Iron Maiden or to further generalise, NWOBHM. So as far as the music is concerned I like it. Its one of those songs that I will gladly hear when I want to concentrate on what I am reading or writing but I wouldnt really notice it when it starts or ends in a bunch of songs sounding similar. But mind you, its a very good powerful song. So dont misunderstand my opinion here. If I have to say anything bad about this song its about the lyrics and probably that Sufi isnt really a heavy metal/hard rock vocalist :)

By now Arbovirus has really convinced me their true message of the album. That of being different. Together their album is like a hand picked collection of the definitive genres of rock music. Its hard to believe at some point that all these songs are done by the same album.

Shekor (Roots) - Grunge ? Alternative ? Cant really put my finger on it once again but the words "pearl" , "jam", "eddie", "vedder" comes to my mind immediately as the guitar lead and the searing vocals take the song to an unexpected crescendo. From the beginning to the end, musically this song stares right into your eye with an attitude that you cant shrug off easily. As I hear the song once again I realise however that this is the penultimate song and if only a little bit Sufi's voice in the initial part of the song is a little repetitive. He does however complete justice to the feel of the song by the second part of the song till the end and according to me this is one song that if you hear as a single it will definitely make you sit up and take notice of Arbovirus.

Shorger Shishura ( Children of Heaven) - Some of you might search for Arbovirus and their songs after reading this and please do so. Many of you who do so will land up in their Wikipedia page. Though written very well I am sad it does not mention anything about this song. To me this song is truly a creation of great creative minds. I will not be able to do justice to the song by this blog. Please listen to it folks and then tell me how you liked it. But to give you a glimpse the song starts with a tv static noise leading onto channel surfing and then settling onto a program that brings the idea that war is essentially the root and personification of all evil. This gives way to sounds of machine gun which leads to the guitar intro. By now I swear I have placed this song on the same pedestal as Civil War by GnR. The haunting lead too reminds you off Slash. Yet the song is slow, melodic focusing on the lyrics, with the music and scale changes doing an excellent job to underline what the song really wants to say. Background vocals are out of the world. Psychedelic and progressive rock influences are evident in the general structure of the song and together with the vocals the song succeeds to create what Arbovirus had probably consciously stayed away from doing - to create an ambience, a story, an atmosphere to put across a message really really well. And so it does. The song stops to a silence at 7:23 only to resume 5 seconds later with a rather innocuous guitar and vocal intro which gives way to a guitar solo that will surely impress you. I really feel guilty trying to explain this song friends because its perfect in what it set out to achieve. If any of you have heard When the Children Cry by White Lion , this song is a 12 minute version of something similar done by Guns and Roses ending with a children's choir accusing the whole manking of being selfish and filling the world with hatred and gunpowder smells. Yes. this song is about politics. It is about middle east and its a goddamn brilliant song.

Arbovirus has achieved a lot in this album according to me. I have been quite late to really understand and analyse the Bangladeshi rock scene. But I am happy that I have been right at the time when Arbo has come to the foreground. I wish I could be a journalist to see these bands evolve but I wish all the best to them and really expect a lot out of them. Someday if ever they break grounds in contemporary Bengali Music and not stop at making one good album and then go into Hindi/Bengali Movie songs I will be happy to remind my friends about this entry and how I said that they should make it really big.

I will end with two lines from their opening song Shikarokti which to me defines their attitude..

".... amar bhoy amakey shahoshi kore
amar paap amakey nishpaap kore....."

In the words of my generation .... jiyo boss!!

Next Band : Nemesis

1st January 2010

Bengali Rock Album Review 3 - Proloyer Shomoye (Insomnia)

This has been long due.
I dont really know why I am writing this now, especially when I am completely sleep deprived but I guess thats my style. To get myself to the edge and then try to write, for I have always thought that thats when I write best.

Also a fellow blogger, a close relative of mine and a regular reader of my blog (when i post that is) -- the same person -- mentioned that prachir should not stay too long as my top page of my blog for that much amount of time. So here goes.. another review..

Insomnia as a band has been on the circuit for a long time. I cursorily knew their guitarist as a fellow guitarist during school life. Did NOT know him personally, and at that time I was just plucking strings and couldnt really call myself a guitarist, but by then, Bodhi had carved niche for himself in the Calcutta School Music circuit. I have known about Insomnia's music since then. Well they didnt form the band till they were almost out of school, South Point that is. But nonetheless Insomnia wasnt and isnt a school band. They started playing English Rock by definition and played the tricky stuff, Dylan, Floyd and later went into alternative especially RATM.

So, when I heard they were releasing a Bengali Rock Album, I was actually surprised and to some extent disheartened, because these guys were one of the few after Krosswindz who played good rock music in Calcutta and although good rock music can exist in the Bengali Language I thought these guys were going for the more exciting competition.

But their first album has impressed me a lot. I mean as a regular and avid listener of music of all types I can comment that their album though carved out of sheer frustation that English Music is not commercially viable in Calcutta, comes out as one of the very best in recent Alternative Bengali Music. For readers who are disgusted at this comment, thinking that I consider all Bengali bands to be the best blah blah, should wait for my later posts about the NOT SO GOOD bengali bands and you will realise that there is no dearth of incompetence.

Moving on to their album which is called Proloyer Shomoye (Times of Armageddon).

This album mostly is about Rage, Protest, Death and all the other dark imagery that one could think of as important issues in our times. So its not surprising that bands like Rage Against The Machine, Audioslave, Payable On Death and sometimes even Blur have had a heavy influence on their music.

So heavy that their title track, Proloyer Shomoye - starts with a guitar solo and a drum riff that immediately reminds you of "Youth of The Nation - P.O.D". The solo and the drum continues in the background through out the song, but the song itself is very very different from the P.O.D song. This very first song gets you head banging by the time it reaches the second stranza. By this time one realises that the lyrics are not straightforward even if they sometimes use very simple language. The lyrics shifts from metaphors to reality a bit too often, but the drums and the guitars take enough care so that you are not disappointed by the end of the song.

The next song, Artonaad (Scream), starts with another very recognizable guitar riff, and continues with it till the time the vocals give the song a different direction than "REVOLVER by RATM". Delay/Echo is probably one of the most favorite effects of this band. I love echo/delay effects, but when you use it to cover up the fact that you have lifted a solo from another band then it isnt really used for a good purpose. Standing out however in this song is the bass. It does give the song a different feel as does the vocals who try to his best to be different from the original and does a good job at it. The lyrics are more straightforward bringing out the small intricate details of life in Calcutta but with at least half a minute to go the song is already too long.

The next song, Shunyo (Zero/Vacuum) has beautiful lyrics. I havent "YET" found a similarity with a song that I have heard before, but the sound is complete. The song is simple in structure with good mood changes and good use of effects at different parts of the song.

But Shunyo does not prepare the listener for the next song. Its not a necessity these days for an album to have all the songs connected. The next song, Niswas (Breath) sounds as if its straight out of an Audioslave album. By now you would have taken the hint that these guys are definitely crazy about Tom Morello and also that they are immensely talented. Otherwise, its not everyday that you would find/hear a band that plays RATM/Audioslave leads with this much ease. This song is a really good song and I fear that the Calcutta audience may not be ready for alternative rock music at these doses. This is a fear I had for Prachir as well but more so for Insomnia because there music is what defines Alternative Bengali Rock and not borderline Metal/Alternative. By now this band has made a mark on my mind as a really really talented musicians.

The next song Hat Dhore (Holding Hands) speaks about the monotony of life and maybe also about Video Gaming. Lyrics are well thought of but the music though really good once again reminds me about some song I have heard of but can't really remember right now. The guitar solo is classic and the song convinces me that this band is not just good but very good. Personally the song stands out from the rest of the album because of its softness and which is the same reason why I dont like it so much .... :) ... but nonetheless I have tried not to be biased. Its a good song and it deserves the praise.


The next song Pothe Ghatey Nekdey Thakey (Wolves Prowl the Roads) is one of my favorite songs of this album. The beginning of the song lets you know its about call-centre professionals and the BPO boom in Calcutta and the rest of India. From their lyrics it seems Insomnia is not particularly happy with the boom and probably express this sentiment with the exceptionally explosive music. I have tried for sometime to pinpoint the influence of this song because it seems to me I have heard it before. But .. till now I havent been successful. I have actually heard all of RATM one by one , then audioslave, then Creed/Alterbridge and SOD just to find the song. And I am happy that I havent found it... yet.. The song is one of the best from the album . The only one negative about this song is the really off key background vocals. The rest is perfect and once again makes me wonder how such an exceptionally produced song and album is going to be accepted in Calcutta which when last I checked was still considering bands like kalapahar as rock bands.

Aakash Chowa (Skyhigh) the next song is one about loneliness and depression, touching another of the common downlows of the modern urban society , which by now I believe is the theme of their album. The starting drum line reminds me of Blur - Song 2. A little bit of search about Insomnia as a band will tell you that they are exceptionally proud of their drummer as being one of the few people in the city to play bounce. If you need to know what that is, listen to the song and imagine how the drum sticks behave if you have to play a rythm like that. Thats a very simplistic explanation of the style but then I am not a drummer. The vocals are really good in this song and so is the arrangement.

If I have not already mentioned it earlier I must say that apart from their brilliance in the music that they play, Insomnia as a band has shown exceptional maturity in the sound production and recording in their very first album. Its true Bodhi has been doing it for some time and its really really paid off.

The next song Adhormer Sar (frankly I am not sure how to translate this .. but it probably is The core of dishonesty or The fertlizer of dishonesty) starts of with the unmistakable riff of Born of a Broken Man by RATM. Talking about human corruptness in general with distinct anti-war tones, this song actually was one of the first songs I had heard from the album. I will not lie to you . After hearing the beginning I went back increased my volume and checked the credits to really believe this was a Bengali Band and not by some weird mechanism RATM singing in Bengali. Adhormer Sar scores points once again in all directions except maybe for originality. But they are once again meticulous in the reproduction of the original, very creative in the improvisations, beautiful in the lyrics and powerful in both vocals and the guitar. The rest of the band although not talked about much by me just fits in very .. very.. well.

Opekkha (The Wait), the last song is a soft soothing song starting with a very simple piano loop. No hard crackling guitars, no growling, no very fancy drumming and to me the most important song for the album if Insomnia is looking for general acceptance. I will try to be as neutral as possible because the song does not really fall on my side of the line for a "Good Song". But the effort and passion behind this song definitely oozes out both from the lyrics as well as the vocals. I could not think of influences for this one and I guess thats okay! :)

All in all, Proloyer Shomoye is an excellent album if one considers the novelty this album has introduced in the Calcutta Rock Music Scene. I am not sure how popular it has been since I have been quite late to review it but the fact that it has stayed on my regular playlist for sometime at a time when I was in a spree for new tunes is without sounding too pompous a definite sign that these guys have got their bengali "rock" absolutely spot on!! :)

The album does get hit on the context of originality and I woudl be eagerly waiting for their next album to see what they are really made of. Insomnia has shown they are the best when it comes to a RATM cover but whether they can scale it one notch up and truly create a new sound of Bengali alternative rock rather than sitting on the shoulder of giants and not even trying to stand is something to wait for..

Well Done Insomnia and please keep it up and dont sell your souls to the commercial strategies of Music World and Planet Ms.. Thats all i really wish for..

Next up : Arbovirus..

29th November, 2009

Go to the Bengali Rock Search Index

Bengali Rock Album Review 2 - Prachir (Prachir)

I have been wanting to do this , ever since I wrote about Cactus' new album. Maybe this time it will be right.

I came across this band , about a day before one of my final exams last semester, trying to find new Indian bands and online radio for the same. I did manage to hear two of their songs and hated them, thinking them to be loose lyrics. The third song from that playlist however caught me and I kept listening to it. Soon the album was in my Itunes and Ipod and the band had almost all their songs from their debut album in my TOP 25 MOST PLAYED list. Later I realised they also made it to the top 6 of the Channel V Launchpad Competition (The only existing reality tv show that seems to make a little bit of sense.. not a lot but still). Its sad that their bassist dumped them in the middle of the show and I wonder if it was a gimmick because they were too good and probably one of the best acts in the country right now. I have asked some of my readers to listen to them but this is the first time I am writing about them. I am talking about Prachir and their self titled debut album.

I originally thought that I would give you guys a clip of every song in the album but then I realised that its just stereotypical and since these guys are anything but that in the current Bengali Rock scenario it was not doing them justice ..

Prachir has a sound that currently very few other Bengali Rock bands possess and the fact that they have reached this sound in their very first album is something to be proud of and also to watch out for. Fossils I remember had an amazing first album and they topped it up with their second album, but as a real Fossils fan I have been disappointed after that. Hopefully Prachir will have their act together for sometime, for they are truly something to hold on to for sometime.

Their first song called Porichoy (deftly termed as Introduction) is a song apparently about drug addiction and it really does have strong lyrics. The words are not exceptionally intricate. I think as a principle Prachir does not try to use high strung words. Their words are simple. This probably gives them that much space to experiment with their fillers. Porichoy is truly a nice introduction although the change of scale in the middle of the song has a little too much of a repetitive lead. The classic second stranza lead is really good. Just by this part of the first song, one would know why I like a band like this.. I mean they give a 40 second (about 8 cycles) guitar solo.... obviously I would like it. The song by now has reached a high pitch with Soumyo's vocals ending the song really well.

The next one is Bharotborsho (India) .The song starts with a heavy lead and would be an instant hit with the metalheads. The lyrics over a period of time will turn out to be once again good and deep lyrics written in very simple language. If these guys really want their lyrics to mean anything, they do so with no nonsense because only then will it reach everyone. I dont love the lead solo of this song too much but just the power of this song takes it through.
By now Prachir has settled into their sound, that boasts of very powerful vocals and an exceptional guitar sound (Bua).

And it is then that their third song Uttorer Bhire (Crowd of Questions). The only thing that I did not like in this songs is the backing vocals. Otherwise this is to me one of their best song. Lyrics are deep and meaningful, the lead vocals is tight and compact, the drumming is spot on and the end solo is brilliant. This is another one for classic hard rock fans and I guarantee this song will not disappoint you.

With three songs with great energy in each of them, I believe they had to have a softer one and this one was Tsunami. The song obviously refers to the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. It has a very soothing effect with the sound with as little distortion as possible. It has a distinguishable keyboard part and all in all it serves its purpose for a small time to gather ones breath. Because the next song - Shrinkhol (Chains) - is arguably one of the hardest songs I have heard from a Bengali Band. Right from the first crash cymbal to the intro lead that sounds very much like Metallica - I disappear to the filler provided by the keyboard with the guitar in the background to the final guitar lead that plays behind the vocals, this song smells, sounds and feels of the real energy these guys are really all about.

Hotash Prithibi (Disappointed Earth), the next song, takes it from where Shrinkhol left it and for those who love double bass drumming, this one is for you. This song drives the point further that Prachir is not here to make soft music about romance. (I might have to eat my words because they might make something like that later considering thats what sells ....unfortunately). But till then, they are here to make some loud music with absolutely precise targets of heart pounding vocals, relentless drumming and classic hard guitars. This song is when I guess the drummer (Ayan) realised that he had not done enough to stand out and he does.

My excitement about these guys when I first heard their album was more about their sound than the individual songs. After a long time Band Music in Calcutta was experimenting with new sounds that were harder and looked towards an underground future and were not scared to do it. The fact that these guys were now being released in the same mainstream label (Asha Audio) who release Porosh Pathor at one point of time does speak of newer Independent Music Labels required for the band scene there, but it also probably talks about the fact that the audience base for such bands is increasing. Progressive/Alternative Rock/Metal has reached the Bengali Band scene and from what it looks like it should stay for some time.


Swadhinota (Freedom) is another such quintessential progressive metal track. Lyrically strong, this song by now fits the Prachir sound perfectly. Once again these guys use keyboards really well. The guitar solo in this song is one to be proud of for any guitarist and give the song a complete feel.

I love an album where I cannot decide which one is really my favorite, because they all sound so good and this one is definitely one of them with Hotash Prithibi, Shrinkhol and Uttorer Bhire all being so close in being the best song. But in the end (and isnt it sooooooo cliched), but there is only one winner and that is the last song - Shrinkhol acoustic version. This is the song that really made me look back at Prachir with respect when I was going to dump them in the folder of Bands Ive heard and not Bands I like.

The acoustic version of Shrinkhol is probably the most listened song in my ipod and you will know if you hear it. I dont think you need to understand Bengali to like it as I found in my lab. My lab boasts of a great sound system with two huge speakers kept at the highest racks so that sound has a really full sound. It is one of the many things i love about my lab. My fellow lab members are very appreciative about good music and a lot of times if I play my music which mostly now consists of newly found Indian/Bengali/Bangladeshi Music and it is worth it I would get a comment saying "Nice song" . Trust me. I am proud of some of the bands from Calcutta and India. My lab members are not Music Critics but they hear a lot of music as well and varied origin and to like a song without understanding the lyrics means a great deal for the Band and evidently for its fan (Me!) It is a strict NO NO in professional circuits to be a fan of the Band you are reviewing , or so I heard, but I guess Im not a professional ...

This song boasts of beautiful vocals, amazing guitar work, but of all brilliant keyboards (Indranil). Its brilliant to find every individual band member making his mark in different songs.
I have always believed and probably even said it here, that a Band represents an unit and even though once in a while there are individuals of whom you will hear more, because they are good looking or more energetic or reveals too much or some other gimmick , it is ultimately the compact complete sound of everybody together that makes it a good BAND. These guys are just that.

A lot of people think that most music I hear to or ask others to , are sort of an acquired taste and may not be taken with the same enthusiasm as it does for me. I believe it. The first song that I heard of Prachir was a song called Bharotborsho. At that point of time, I felt that the lyrics were too amateur. Trust me, after hearing the album for some time not only I like them, but I think some of their other songs are truly one of the very fresh lyrics I have heard of late.

All in all I consider Prachir to be one of the MOST promising bands to watch out for in the Bengali Band Music Industry.

PS: I havent talked about their bassist not only because there are no stand out bass riffs in their music but also because I dont respect him too much after what he did to the band while Channel V Launch pad was going on. If it was a gimmick its okay i guess. But otherwise.. I support Vishal Dadlani when he raised the finger to the screen and asked the bassist to **** off for dumping his band midway like that.

Next Band to be reviewed - Insomnia.

For those interested in more non music related blogs.. please wait. It will take time for me to come back to my self.. After all I really was out of writing for quiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiite some time! :)

Take care folks. Till then, do try to listen to these guys. Myspace and esnips are good places to hear their entire album.

18th October, 2009


Go to the Bengali Rock Search Index.

Introduction and Bengali Rock Album Review 1 - Tuchho (Cactus)

Hello people,


I have been trying to review Bengali Rock Albums and Bands in my other blog - psychocancer.blogspot.com but I think it would be much better if I could put them all at one place and maybe even include a link to their songs on youtube or somewhere else. More like indianrockmp3.com


So this is where I start. The first few blogs will of course be from earlier since I am shifting their bases but new posts will soon be coming up. And please dont feel shy to send me a link for a new band or a new album in Bengali Rock Genre. I will listen to them and then review it.


Thanks a lot guys


Parag Mahanti.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Cactus -  Tuchho

I just heard all the song's of Cactus' new album, Tuchho. I am sure those who are in Calcutta would have heard it a long time back and well due to internet I should also hear it around the same time. But somehow eventhough a close friend of mine had told me about it a few weeks back I did not get the time to actually download the songs on to my computer, and hearing from the internet meant a lot of unnecessary hassle, especially just to listen to the songs once. As an afterthought I think downloading the songs was a good idea because after listening to the album about three - four times I have actually started liking the songs a lot. This is a characteristic of few good albums and eventhough there is absolutely no comparison and I would be committing a blasphemy by naming both of these albums in the same page as Tuchho but then I felt the same thing about The Wall and A Brand New Day, when I first heard them. It took me about 4-5 repetitions of the album back to back (for both of them, obviously at different times) to actually realise that I love the albums... so much so that they both remain as one of the all time best albums in my database. However Tuchho I think has already reached its plateau. I wont like it more than this but I do like it quite a bit


Anyways, coming back to the point..I was intrigued by the completely different musical philosophy cactus followed in this album. It was way too different from what they had been creating from their beginning way back in the 90s. They still have two vocalists, but wait for it...

the other vocalist is no more a pop artist desperately trying to be a rocker. The other "one" , apart from siddhartha (Sidhu) is Sayak Bandopadhyay, ex Lakkhichara , and student of Pt. Ajoy Chakraborti , and therefore with a tremendous Hindusthani Classical Expertise. I did not sense that it was Sayak whose voice stood out in the songs like Masiha as the Classical vocal but I could distinctly realise that there was a change. A big one. This reminded me of a Calcutta Times artice that I read last summer when I was preparing for my trip to US that Cactus had completely disbanded but were coming up with a new group with Sidhu still being there. As it so happens, Cactus has come back with a completely new line up and for those who loved Holud Pakhi, I would only say, wait for it , because this new line up is extremely good.


First of all, their new guitarist, Allan (and I really dont know which other band he is from, although he does remind me of the Magdalene guitarist) is fantastic. I think one of the main reasons why the sound of Cactus has changed from a pop-ish, mushy semi-rock to a much more distinct and clear, straightforward rock genre is because of the inclusion of this new guitarist. He has touches that in contemporary Bengali music can only be seen in Fossils and some of the other Hard Metal Bangladeshi Bands but if I have to pose like a professional critic and actually comment and compare his skills with the axe I would say this guy is going to make Cactus much sharper and way ahead of other bands...Partha (Fossils) should really watch out.


But I guess there are two other things that needs to be mentioned before I go back to Sayak's contribution once again and that is obviously the Bass for one and the keyboards for the other. Baji is still on the drums and doing a great job at it. He always did. For those who have heard Cactus for quite some time would know that although they have never made the drums a quintessential part of their music (earlier) without it Holud Pakhi would not have the side stick sound, Buddho Hesechhey would not have the rythm and Sudhu Tumi Elena would not have the filler riffs.

But by having a new bassist not only has their set become tighter but also more prominent. With their new, harder, more guitar oriented songs a prominent bass is really important and I think this guy does justice to that order.

Buti, their keyboardist, was if I am not wrong a part of Insomnia, a Calcutta based Rock Band, primarly performing in English, and although I dont know whats their scene now, I do know that at some point of time two years back they were regulars at Someplace Else. I know Insomnia because of their guitarist , Bodhi, I think from South Point. He was what you call the Hendrix maniac, in the school rock circuit when we were at high school. I did not know him personally but did hear him a few times . But we are not talking about him.We are talking about Buti who played keyboards for Insomnia then and now for Cactus, and does a great job at it. The keyboards sometimes along with a small tinge of bluesy guitar riffs reminds me , in some songs of Animals from Floyd and one or two tunes from Doors. But that does not harm anything. These are influences and in no way covers or plagiarisms.


That brings me to Sidhu and Sayak.

Cactus has always been a very much vocal based band. Some of you would question me what is a vocal based band. All bands are vocal based. Not really. Yes its true you need good vocals to make the songs a part of memory but what I mean by vocal based band is the difference between say Queen and Floyd. Freddie Mercury was almost all of Queen. Yes they had some good music but it was essentially just him. Whereas Floyd, who remembers who sang which song? The only song Floyd ever got a Grammy for is one without lyrics! (Not that I give Grammies too much importance, but I guess I could spend another para or two to drive the point home as to what I mean by vocal based band but then trying to think about any otherBlogger: I Dont Know - Create Post Bengali Band that was not vocal based brings me only and only to Mohiner Ghoraguli and Crosswindz. Yes in no way am I being disrespectful towards Gautam Chattopadhay or Tuki or Neil or Chandrani. I am just saying that they made their music their ESP and not necessarily their voices.


If Allan is the spark plug to the Internal Combustion Engine of Cactus, or should I say, the New Cactus, then Sayak is definitely more gasoline with high octane content. And Cactus, especially Sidhu and the rest are not a low performance engine. They have been there and survived the savagery of everything, starting from the critiques of "intellectual" who wrote off Bengali Rock Music as a western cultural (mlechho sanskriti) influence and thus wanted to stay away from it - to the entry of thousands and thousands of 4 memebered youth projects who call themselves rock bands and at the end of the day would consider Bryan Adams and Enrique to be good examples of rock music.


Sayaks bold vocals strikes out in most of the songs and Sidhu and himself have shared the mike really well. They have given each other the opportunity to come out and show the rest why Cactus has been their so long. I was never a big fan of Cactus, primarily because even though they had been there for so long they were not doing much about it but I guess they were waiting and now they have found their sun. True to their name they have survived for over 15 years and even though they have only produced 3 albums in that 15 years compared to say the 30000 that other small bands have manufactured in their 15month infancy.. but Tuchho has done justice to the calibre this band promises to prove and also does justice to the dream Cactus (as a band, with or without its band members) started... that of creating contemporary music for the Bengali youth.


I believe they will do well if they hold on. Just in case I did not mention it clearly I do like their album, probably also because they over use echo...and I myself being an echo freak, especially with Floyd in my veins..it definitely appeals a lot more.


Anyways. I will end here. This post was written inside my lab, and I guess I should do something about the testtubes with my sample in them or else some of them would start singing Tuchho Ami... !!!!


PS: For those who want to listen to the songs there is a blogspot website which has all the songs in a downloadable format. Simply search as Cactus Tuchho Blogspot and you will reach your destination. Till next time , Take care.


12th April 2009

Go to the Bengali Rock Search Index